Showing posts with label 10th Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 10th Amendment. Show all posts

Saturday, April 22, 2017

Victory for Liberty: Asset Forfeiture Reform in Arizona

REPRINT of a MESSAGE FROM
Mike Maharrey of the TENTH AMENDMENT CENTER
April 22, 2017

The Tenth Amendment Center celebrated a major legislative victory last week. And it proves how much impact a small, dedicated group of activists can make at the state level.

Last Wednesday, Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey signed a bill reforming the state’s civil asset forfeiture laws. The new law also takes on federal forfeiture programs by banning prosecutors from circumventing state laws by passing off cases to the feds in most situations.

Rep. Eddie Farnsworth (R-Gilbert) sponsored House Bill 2477 (HB2477). The new law will require prosecutors to establish a higher evidentiary standard for asset forfeiture. Under the old standard, law enforcement could take somebody’s property based merely on the preponderance of the evidence. HB2477 raises the bar, requiring police and prosecutors to provide “clear and convincing evidence” the property was linked to a crime. The law also includes stricter reporting requirements and oversight on the spending of forfeiture proceeds. While the new law will not require a criminal conviction before proceeding with asset forfeiture, it takes a step toward reforming Arizona law under a tougher standard.

This is a huge win.

Now, some people will say this isn’t that big of a deal. After all, it’s a relatively modest reform. But you have to understand Arizona politics to grasp just how significant it is to get this bill signed into law.

When some activists in the state told me they were going to push for forfeiture reform last fall, I thought to myself, ‘No freakin’ way!’

You see, law enforcement lobbyists have an amazing amount of influence in Arizona politics. I’ve seen them kill so many bills there over the last few years, I was extremely pessimistic that any kind of reform could get done – much less something as significant as closing a loophole that lets cops pass off cases to the feds and the collect up to 80 percent of the forfeiture proceeds through the federal Equitable Sharing program.

But I underestimated the power of activism.

This group of grassroots folks who pushed HB2477 through the process wasn’t big. Maybe 20 people – if that. But they worked their butts off. They held weekly conference calls. They visited legislators in Phoenix. They made phone calls. They attended hearings. They sent out emails. They countered all of the arguments by lobbyists. And they motivated others in the state to put the pressure on their legislators. I know for a fact the bill was dead in committee at one point. But somehow these grassroots heroes managed to apply enough pressure on the committee chair to get a hearing.

Seriously. This is huge. I really can’t properly convey here what a David-versus-Goliath story this is. A little volunteer force of everyday Arizonians with no money beat the crap out of coordinated, well-funded lobbyists.

This is how we win, ladies and gentlemen. This group of people isn’t special. They were just committed to a cause and willing to put in a little time and effort to advance liberty.

So often, we feel like there is nothing we can do. I hear it all the time. There is a sense of hopelessness. And maybe if you’re focusing on changing Washington D.C., that’s true. It’s amazing how fast Trump ran into the arms of the establishment, isn’t it?

But at the state and local level – you can make a difference.

So pick a cause. Commit to it. Organize and get stuff done!

 

Friday, May 27, 2011

Break the Cycle: Trimming RI Government One Grant at a Time, Part I

Have you ever wondered how so many states came to be in such debt? How has government grown so big and expensive? Do you believe politicians when they say there's no place left to cut?

One debt factor is the old trick and ugly trap of unfunded mandates.

What are they? 

Those in charge of the federal government have 2 motives: (1) they need to justify their own jobs, and (2) they want more control over you so they can justify their own jobs. Therefore, whatever hare-brained idea for more social engineering pops into the latest bureaucrat or czar's head, it gets proposed.

But because of that pesky 10th Amendment in the United States Constitution declaring state sovereignty, the federal government can't directly replace state authority.

Instead, Washington dangles the carrot of federal grants to successfully coerce compliance. Cash-strapped municipalities and states eagerly grab the "free" money. I'll avoid the obvious point that you and I are still the source of that "free" money, even if local politicians are too stupid or too sly to admit it. So, states willingly adopt policies, pass laws, create new or expand existing bureaucracies, and implement programs they would never consider of their own volition -- and usually step on your liberty in some way, but that's another topic. To politicians accepting the "free" money, tomorrow's strings are of little consequence in light of today's financial windfall.

Oops! Tomorrow is Today!  

However, federal grant monies dry up after a couple of years, and states and cities are left with more employees, more departments, more equipment, more office space, more mandates to perform more programs. But no more money.

So, it comes to a decision: scrap the program and lay off the workers (as if the unions would permit that nonsense!), or find a way to fund the whole thing through existing funds or - far more likely - borrowing money. Or raising taxes.

Can you name a government program that has been eliminated in the past 10 years? I can't either.

Now consider that what I describe is for one grant, one program. Realize that the pattern is repeated over and over. 


Did You Say, "Nothing Left to Cut"?

Is it becoming clearer how we got where we are? Local governments don't cut programs when federal money runs out; after all, the "new" program is now a couple of years old and has developed an expectation of a "service" that must continue, right?

I say, "Wrong!" Rethink those unfunded mandates. Better yet, don't even accept the federal money in the first place. But if local government does accept a grant, then have the testicular fortitude to end the program when the money ends.

And what about federal taxes? When the feds no longer fund a particular program and the cost shifts to local government, do your federal taxes go down to make up for hike in local taxes? Of course not. The feds dream up another liberty-clipping, social engineering project to propose and fund.

Current example for Rhode Island? The Race to the Top education grant. That's Part II.